11939 N. Meridian St., Carmel, IN 46032, United States
Wagner Reese, LLP is an Indiana personal injury law firm founded in 1997 by co-founders Stephen M. Wagner and Jason R. Reese. Serving clients throughout the state, the firm has recovered more than $200 million on behalf of negligence victims...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout Wagner Reese
Wagner Reese, LLP is an Indiana Personal Injury law firm founded in 1997 by co-founders Stephen M. Wagner and Jason R. Reese. Serving clients throughout the state, the firm has recovered more than $200 million on behalf of negligence victims and their families, including a $22 million wrongful death settlement and a $14 million settlement for an abuse victim.
The firm handles claims involving Medical Malpractice, wrongful death, catastrophic injuries, nursing home and elder neglect, Product Liability, and abuse. Its seven attorneys bring over 150 years of combined legal experience, supported by a staff of paralegals and intake specialists across multiple Indiana offices.
Co-founder Stephen Wagner was named Indiana Trial Lawyer of the Year in 2006 and has been recognized as an Indiana Super Lawyer nearly every year since 2004. Co-founder Jason Reese has been listed among Indiana's top medical malpractice trial lawyers. The firm maintains offices in Carmel, Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, West Lafayette, and Evansville, and serves clients in South Bend and across northern Indiana.
Wagner Reese: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of Wagner Reese?
Wagner Reese earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 88/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 5-star client rating. Founded in 1997 by Stephen M. Wagner and Jason R. Reese, this Indiana personal injury firm counts documented eight-figure recoveries, including a $22 million wrongful-death result. Wagner, admitted in 1994, sits on the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association board and was named the association's Trial Lawyer of the Year.
Reputation & results
- 5★ · 73 reviews Client rating
- Leaf v. Shelnutt, 400 F.3d 1070 (7th Cir. 2005) Published appellate decision Founding partner litigated this published Seventh Circuit civil-rights decision (Sec. 1983 / Fourth Amendment), the matter for which he was named Indiana Trial Lawyer of the Year.
- Documented recoveries incl. $22M wrongful death, $17M gas-explosion, $14M abuse settlement Track record Multiple documented eight-figure settlements and recoveries across wrongful death, catastrophic injury and product liability.
Experience
- 32+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead/founding partner Stephen M. Wagner admitted to the Indiana bar in 1994.
- Active, good standing - no public discipline found Bar standing Stephen M. Wagner, Indiana State Bar Association member; no public disciplinary record located.
Recognition
- Indiana Trial Lawyers Association - Board of Directors; named ITLA "Trial Lawyer of the Year" Bar leadership & honor Founding partner serves on the ITLA Board of Directors and was selected by the association as Indiana Trial Lawyer of the Year (2006) for Leaf v. Sheriff of Marion County.
- Peer-recognized; National Trial Lawyers Top 100 (Civil Plaintiff) Peer & industry recognition Lead partner recognized by peers over 20+ consecutive years and named to a national civil-plaintiff trial lawyers Top 100.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about Wagner Reese
Last update: May 22, 2026
Wagner Reese holds a 5.0-star average across more than 70 Google reviews from the personal injury clients it represents throughout Indiana. Reviewers describe attorneys who are skilled, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in the people they represent, naming Tim Devereux and Laura Swafford among the team members who handled their cases.
Steady communication is a constant in the feedback — clients describe being kept informed at every stage and never left wondering where their case stood. Reviewers also point to results, with one client noting the firm secured more than the defendant's insurer had originally been willing to pay, and others describing settlements they considered fair after careful, thorough work.
Compassion comes up alongside competence: reviewers repeatedly say the attorneys made a difficult time easier and treated them as more than a case file. The overall picture is of a firm that combines courtroom capability with attentive, supportive client care.
Recent client quotes
We received more than the defendants insurance company wanted to originally pay. If you are looking for a good personal injury attorney choose Laura Swafford.
Tim's level of compassion for those who have been injured is extraordinary and it shows in how he advocates for his clients.
From the very beginning, they were professional, attentive, and kept me informed every step of the way. Their expertise and dedication resulted in a fair settlement.
Similar Attorneys
The Burkhalter Law Firm
The Burkhalter Law Firm is a three-lawyer trial practice in downtown Knoxville that represents employees, whistleblowers and seriously injured people…
View profile
Dodson & Hooks
Dodson & Hooks is a Baton Rouge plaintiff's firm built around maritime and admiralty litigation, with founding partner Richard J.…
View profile
The Richards Firm
The Richards Firm is a personal injury practice based in Hamilton, Ohio, founded in 2020 by attorney Rhys Richards. Before…
View profile