621 E Town St, Columbus, OH 43215, United States
The Fitch Law Firm LLC is a Columbus personal injury practice founded by trial lawyer John K. Fitch, and the firm traces its work for injured Ohioans back to 1980. Its caseload centers on serious injury and death claims: car,...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout The Fitch Law Firm
The Fitch Law Firm LLC is a Columbus Personal Injury practice founded by trial lawyer John K. Fitch, and the firm traces its work for injured Ohioans back to 1980. Its caseload centers on serious injury and death claims: car, truck, motorcycle and rideshare crashes, construction and industrial accidents, traumatic brain injuries and medical negligence. It also brings civil cases for survivors of sexual abuse, an area where the firm has helped shape Ohio law.
Fitch earned his law degree at the University of Dayton and his undergraduate degree at Ohio State. He worked as an associate at two Ohio firms before opening his own practice. He served as president of the Central Ohio Association for Justice and spent a decade on the Ohio Association for Justice board of trustees. Attorney Kirstin Peterson, a 2019 graduate of the Ohio State University Moritz College of Law, works alongside him on motor vehicle, Wrongful Death and abuse cases.
The firm's best-known matter is Amanda Brandt's lawsuit against her childhood abuser, which ended in a $134 million Cuyahoga County jury verdict in 2019. Fitch and Peterson then took the damages question to the Supreme Court of Ohio. In Brandt v. Pompa (2022), the court ruled that the state's cap on noneconomic damages could not be applied to her award. On the medical negligence side, the firm reports a $2.65 million malpractice recovery.
Besides the Columbus headquarters on East Town Street, the firm lists offices in Dayton, Springfield, Marion, Delaware and Newark, and offers free consultations to clients across Ohio.
The Fitch Law Firm: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of The Fitch Law Firm?
The Fitch Law Firm earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 90/100 (Exceptional), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.9-star client rating. Founder John K. Fitch was counsel of record for Amanda Brandt, whose $134 million verdict led to the Ohio Supreme Court's 2022 ruling in Brandt v. Pompa. A past president of the Central Ohio Association for Justice, he has represented injured Ohioans since 1980.
Reputation & results
- 4.89★ · 290 reviews Client rating
- $134M jury verdict; Brandt v. Pompa, 2022-Ohio-4525 Track record Counsel of record for Amanda Brandt. A Cuyahoga County jury awarded $134M in total, including $100M in punitive damages. The Supreme Court of Ohio then held the noneconomic damages cap unconstitutional as applied to her.
Experience
- 45+ yrs in practice Years licensed The firm says it has served injured clients since 1980, and a directory profile lists 46 years of practice. His Ohio registration number is 0008119. The Supreme Court of Ohio registry could not be reached, so the admission year is not officially confirmed.
- Ohio, plus NY, GA and DC Bar admissions Admitted in Ohio courts and the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Northern Districts of Ohio. Also lists New York (registered), Georgia (inactive) and D.C.
Recognition
- Past president, Central Ohio Association for Justice Bar association leadership President 1995-96; Ohio Association for Justice board of trustees 1992-2002; past president of the Franklin County Trial Lawyers' Association.
- Peer-recognized Peer recognition The firm site shows a top peer-review rating and several trial-lawyer honors.
- Author and CLE presenter Teaching & publications Author of the Ohio Guide Book for Auto Accident Victims. Has given CLE talks for the Ohio Academy of Trial Lawyers, the Columbus Bar Association and the Cleveland Academy of Trial Attorneys.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about The Fitch Law Firm
Last update: October 15, 2026
The Fitch Law Firm holds a 4.9-star Google rating from about 290 reviews, and the written feedback is uniformly positive. Injury clients describe a firm that keeps them informed at every step, answers calls and texts promptly, and negotiates down medical bills, liens and subrogation claims so that more of the settlement reaches them.
John Fitch and attorney Kirstin Peterson are praised by name, along with paralegals and assistants such as Ambar, Becky and Briana. Several reviewers describe the firm taking over after a previous lawyer stalled, including a traumatic brain injury claim resolved after a two-and-a-half-year fight, and others note staff driving to clients' homes to notarize forms or waiting after hours so a client could collect a settlement check.
Recent client quotes
They negotiated my medical bills and liens on my behalf which made a big difference in how much I actually received from my settlement.
Mr. Fitch and his team were able to start behind the eight ball and move everything forward.
His team negotiated down my medical fees and subrogation claims, including the lien my former firm placed on my settlement.
Similar Attorneys
Ruhmann Law Firm
At the Ruhmann Law Firm, our personal injury attorneys in El Paso, Texas will clearly explain your legal rights after…
View profile
Tamaki Law
Tamaki Law has represented injured people across Washington State since 1994. Founded by trial lawyer Blaine L. Tamaki, the firm…
View profile
The Norris Law Group
The Norris Law Group is a Shreveport firm led by attorney Ebonee Rhodes Norris, whose practice spans criminal defense, personal…
View profile