2940 N Swan Rd #212, Tucson, AZ 85712, United States

Smith & Wamsley is an Arizona community association and real estate law firm, founded when Jason E. Smith and Kaycee Scarr Wamsley left the statewide practice where they had worked together to build a smaller, locally run alternative. The firm...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Smith & Wamsley's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Smith & Wamsley

Smith & Wamsley is an Arizona community association and Real Estate Law firm, founded when Jason E. Smith and Kaycee Scarr Wamsley left the statewide practice where they had worked together to build a smaller, locally run alternative. The firm works out of Plaza Palomino in midtown Tucson and a second office in the Ahwatukee area of Phoenix, and describes itself as veteran- and woman-owned.

Most of the work involves homeowners associations, condominium boards, housing cooperatives, landlords, developers and individual property owners: governing-document drafting and CC&R amendments, assessment collection, covenant enforcement, fair-housing questions and insurance-defense litigation. Jason Smith is one of a short list of attorneys certified by the State Bar of Arizona as a specialist in real estate law, and a Fellow of the College of Community Association Lawyers, a national group of roughly 200 attorneys. Kaycee Wamsley brings an NYU master of laws in taxation to a litigation practice covering trusts and estates, Collections and commercial landlord-tenant disputes.

Five attorneys now practice at the firm, several of them University of Arizona law graduates, and the team also handles employment matters, nonprofit corporate work and Personal Injury cases. Smith publishes a weekly newsletter, Friday Fragments, that translates Arizona association law for board members and community managers, and has lectured on fair housing at the CAI National Law Conference.

Independent analysis · Public records

Smith & Wamsley: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
71 / 100
Strong

What is the reputation and track record of Smith & Wamsley?

Smith & Wamsley holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 71/100 (Strong), based on public records and client feedback, with a 2.7-star client rating that reflects reviews from homeowners on the receiving end of association enforcement rather than from the firm own clients. Jason E. Smith is an Arizona certified specialist in real estate law, active with no discipline, and a Fellow of the College of Community Association Lawyers.

Smith & Wamsley — LawyerUp.Network Score 71/100

Reputation & results

54 / 100
  • 2.7★ · 14 reviews Client rating
  • Counsel of record in published Arizona appellate opinions, incl. Chula Vista Homeowners Ass'n v. Irwin, 245 Ariz. 249 / 426 P.3d 1228 (App. 2018) and Gelb v. Dep't of Fire, Building & Life Safety, 225 Ariz. 515 / 241 P.3d 512 (App. 2010) Published appellate decisions Both reporter citations verified against published Arizona Court of Appeals decisions naming the attorney as counsel of record.
  • Defense verdict in a $2M condominium mold case (DiFrank v. Ventana Vista, C20143404) and on $500K trespass/diminution claims (Sandoval v. Red Adobe Pass HOA, C20163673) Defense verdicts Pima County Superior Court case numbers given, outcomes not independently published.

Experience

87 / 100
  • 25 years (admitted 2001; Arizona 2004) Years licensed Founding partner Jason E. Smith; Arizona admission 9/13/2004, earlier Indiana admission 2001.
  • Active, discipline: none Bar standing Arizona registry record loaded and read directly.
  • Instructor of the Year, Arizona Association of Community Managers; board member, CAI Southern Arizona chapter (2012-2014, 2016-2018); lecturer at the CAI National Law Conference Teaching and industry leadership Stated in the attorney's own biography on his State Bar of Arizona profile.

Recognition

89 / 100
  • Certified Specialist in Real Estate Law, State Bar of Arizona (since 2024) Board certification Appears on the State Bar of Arizona's official roster of real estate law certified specialists.
  • Fellow, College of Community Association Lawyers Selective fellowship CCAL admits roughly 200 attorneys nationwide across about 30 states; Smith was named among its newest fellows in a December 2024 CCAL announcement.

Credentials

Education

JD, Indiana University Maurer School of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in AZ Admitted in IN

Professional Associations

Community Associations Institute Pima County Bar Association State Bar of Arizona Real Property Law Section Certified Pro Bono Counsel (State Bar of Arizona)
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Smith & Wamsley

Last update: September 23, 2026

2.7
Based on 14 reviews (via Google)

Smith & Wamsley's reviews split cleanly along which side of a community association dispute the reviewer sits on, and the firm's aggregate rating reflects that split rather than a uniform verdict. Property managers and association board members describe attorney Jason E. Smith as reliable, well-versed in Arizona HOA law and quick to respond, with one management company recommending the firm's retainer program to every association it manages and another reviewer noting office staff are consistently reachable.

The negative reviews come from the opposite direction: homeowners on the receiving end of association enforcement or collection notices. One describes three days of calls and voicemails to the two attorneys named on her notice, being routed to a paralegal, receiving replies she felt were automated, and finally being told she could not speak to an attorney at all. Another describes a poor front-desk interaction when collecting a receipt without an appointment. Both concern access and handling rather than the substance of the legal position.

This is a recognizable pattern for a firm whose clients are associations rather than individual owners: the people writing the critical reviews are adverse parties, not clients. Homeowners should read the rating with that in mind. Boards and managers evaluating the firm should note that the positive reviews come from repeat institutional clients, while the critical ones flag limited attorney access for non-clients contacting the office.

Responsiveness 2.5/5
Expertise 3.2/5
Case outcomes 3.0/5

Recent client quotes

His steady, knowledgeable approach makes him an excellent attorney in the HOA industry. He's a trusted partner who always delivers.
Gabino T. via Google
We always hear back from them very promptly and get very thorough information. We recommend their firm and their retainer program to all of the associations we manage.
Pamela V. via Google
After 3 days of calling both attorneys and leaving messages I receive a call from paralegal Maggie... Telling me I'm unable to speak to an attorney at any time.
Karie N. via Google
View more Google reviews