6405 Century Ave STE 103, Middleton, WI 53562, United States

At Mays Law Office, LLC, we know that you are seeking an attorney because something difficult is happening in your life. Whether you were recently charged with a crime or suffered a serious injury at work, our attorneys take every...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Mays Law Office, LLC's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Mays Law Office, LLC

At Mays Law Office, LLC, we know that you are seeking an attorney because something difficult is happening in your life. Whether you were recently charged with a crime or suffered a serious injury at work, our attorneys take every step to make you feel comfortable and secure a positive outcome in your case. At Mays Law Office, LLC, our Criminal Defense Attorney in Madison, WI, and Workers' Compensation attorneys offer the compassionate legal advocacy you need to help get you back on your feet.

If you need a Drunk Driving Attorney in La Crosse, WI, our experienced legal team is here to defend your rights and guide you through the legal process. Working Hours:
Monday: 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Tuesday: 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Wednesday: 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Thursday: 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Friday: 08:00 AM - 05:00 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

Independent analysis · Public records

Mays Law Office, LLC: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
90 / 100
Exceptional

What is the reputation and track record of Mays Law Office, LLC?

Mays Law Office, LLC holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 90/100 (Exceptional), based on public records and client feedback, with a 5-star client rating. Lead attorney Stephen E. Mays, admitted in Wisconsin in 1995, is a past president of the Dane County Criminal Defense Lawyers' Association and a peer-recognized criminal defense attorney. His documented results include suppressing a breath test in a third-offense OWI case that led to dismissal.

Mays Law Office, LLC — LawyerUp.Network Score 90/100

Reputation & results

92 / 100
  • 5★ · 101 reviews Client rating
  • OWI breath-test suppressed; case dismissed Track record Documented motion to suppress in a 3rd-offense OWI: officer admitted the field sobriety (HGN) test was not administered per NHTSA training; court found no probable cause, suppressed the breath test, and the case was dismissed.

Experience

93 / 100
  • 31+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead attorney Stephen E. Mays admitted to the Wisconsin bar in 1995.
  • Active, good standing - no public discipline Bar standing Active member of the State Bar of Wisconsin; no public disciplinary record found.

Recognition

83 / 100
  • Past President, county criminal defense bar association Bar leadership Stephen E. Mays served as Past President of the Dane County Criminal Defense Lawyers' Association.
  • Peer-recognized in criminal defense (multiple years) Peer recognition Lead attorney recognized by a peer-reviewed legal rating service across multiple years (2011-2016, 2025) for criminal defense / DUI-DWI.

Credentials

Education

JD, Thomas M. Cooley Law School

Bar Admissions

Admitted in WI

Professional Associations

Dane County Criminal Defense Lawyers' Association (Past President) National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers National College for DUI Defense
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Mays Law Office, LLC

Last update: May 21, 2026

5.0
Based on 101 reviews (via Google)

Mays Law Office, LLC draws consistent praise from clients across its three practice areas — criminal defense, personal injury, and workers' compensation. Reviewers describe Attorney Steve Mays handling OWI and criminal charges with concrete results, including reduced charges, dropped counts, and dismissals routed through diversion programs. On the workers' compensation side, Attorney Lisa Pierobon Mays is repeatedly named for taking on denied claims, including one severe work injury Work Comp had refused for a year before she pursued and won a settlement.

Communication is a recurring theme: clients describe being kept informed step by step, getting questions answered along the way, and feeling that the firm absorbed the procedural burden — "takes care of all the court stuff for you, so no need to show up." Reviewers also emphasize a personal, supportive approach during stressful situations, with one calling Lisa "compassionate, thorough, and incredibly knowledgeable" and another describing being given back "my life back my dignity as a human being."

On fees, one reviewer specifically flags Mays Law as charging fairly compared to local alternatives that quoted $5,000–$8,000 for similar criminal matters. Outcomes mentioned in reviews span reduced OWI charges, misdemeanor dismissals via DPP assessment, won workers' compensation cases after initial denial, and settlements maximized late in negotiation. The 5.0-star aggregate across 101 reviews aligns with the consistent positive sentiment in the available review text.

Responsiveness 5.0/5
Expertise 4.9/5
Transparency on fees 4.6/5
Case outcomes 5.0/5

Recent client quotes

Steve and his team are great. They were able to bring my first offense OWI charges down significantly AND get some related charges dropped. He is happy to answer any questions you have along the way, and takes care of all the court stuff for you.
Will C. via Google
She was compassionate, thorough, and incredibly knowledgeable. She made sure he understood every step of the process, fought hard on his behalf, and never let him feel discouraged. Thanks to her dedication, he won his case.
Misty via Google
Their charges are very fair from any other law firm — other law firms will charge you $5000 or $8000 for a criminal charge. I'm really blessed and thankful that I was able to find them at the right time.
Larry B. via Google