414 D'Onofrio Drive, Suite 300, Madison, WI 53719, United States

Koritzinsky Legal Group is a boutique law firm in Madison, Wisconsin, established in 1982 and rooted in over four decades of trusted legal service. The firm brings more than sixty years of combined attorney experience to a focused set of...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Koritzinsky Legal Group's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Koritzinsky Legal Group

Koritzinsky Legal Group is a boutique law firm in Madison, Wisconsin, established in 1982 and rooted in over four decades of trusted legal service. The firm brings more than sixty years of combined attorney experience to a focused set of practice areas, with particular strength in landlord-tenant law, real estate transactions, Estate Planning, and Collections.

The firm represents landlords across Wisconsin in all aspects of rental property management and dispute resolution, from lease drafting and security deposit matters to eviction proceedings and fair housing compliance. Their real estate practice extends to both residential and commercial transactions, providing comprehensive legal support for buyers, sellers, and investors throughout Dane County and the surrounding region.

Beyond landlord-tenant and real estate work, Koritzinsky Legal Group handles estate planning, probate administration, Adoption and termination of parental rights, guardianships, business planning, and debt collection matters. The firm's six-attorney team is known for delivering responsive, accessible counsel that prioritizes clear communication and straightforward legal advice.

Located on Madison's west side at 414 D'Onofrio Drive, the firm serves clients throughout southern Wisconsin with dependable representation grounded in decades of practice.

Independent analysis · Public records

Koritzinsky Legal Group: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
74 / 100
Strong

What is the reputation and track record of Koritzinsky Legal Group?

Koritzinsky Legal Group earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 74/100 (Strong), based on public records and client feedback, with a 3.4-star client rating. The Madison, Wisconsin boutique was established in 1982 by Jay D. Koritzinsky, who was admitted to the state bar in 1980. A University of Wisconsin Law School graduate, he holds the top AV Preeminent peer rating for legal ability and ethics and has practiced without any public disciplinary record.

Koritzinsky Legal Group — LawyerUp.Network Score 74/100

Reputation & results

62 / 100
  • 3.4★ · 13 reviews Client rating

Experience

95 / 100
  • 46+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead attorney Jay D. Koritzinsky admitted to the Wisconsin bar in 1980; founded the practice in 1982.
  • Active, good standing - no public discipline found Bar standing No public disciplinary record located in the Wisconsin Office of Lawyer Regulation public discipline list.

Recognition

70 / 100
  • Highest peer rating for legal ability & ethics Peer-recognized Lead attorney holds the top peer-review rating (AV Preeminent) based on legal ability and ethical standards.

Credentials

Education

JD, University of Wisconsin Law School

Bar Admissions

Admitted in WI

Professional Associations

State Bar of Wisconsin Dane County Bar Association
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Koritzinsky Legal Group

Last update: May 21, 2026

3.4
Based on 13 reviews (via Google)

Koritzinsky Legal Group receives polarized feedback on its eviction and family law practice. One client praised Attorney Koritzinsky's patient communication and reasonable fees in a protracted tenant dispute that settled favorably before trial. However, multiple clients allege serious concerns about the firm's handling of evictions, citing instances where the firm filed cases with deliberately misspelled tenant names, pursued frivolous dismissals, and allegedly misrepresented lease status to public agencies. In family law, a client reported biased billing (single-party charges for joint mediation services) and errors in scheduling that were attributed to the client rather than the firm.

The firm's approach in landlord-tenant disputes has generated complaints of aggressive tactics and documentation issues. Reviewers describe instances of eviction filings despite tenants already being removed from leases, requests to seal cases to avoid public scrutiny, and communications with authorities that clients characterize as misleading. One client reported positive resolution after months of negotiation, suggesting the firm can achieve outcomes through settlement. In mediation and divorce matters, clients express concerns about neutrality and internal communication errors.

Given the mixed nature of reviews—ranging from appreciation for clear communication and fair fees to serious allegations of unethical conduct—prospective clients should carefully vet the firm's approach to their specific legal needs and consider requesting references or reviewing public case records before engagement.

Responsiveness 3.4/5
Expertise 2.9/5
Transparency on fees 2.9/5
Case outcomes 2.9/5

Recent client quotes

Attorney Koritzinsky was patient and provided clear communication with an issue involving a tenant...The rates were very reasonable...Would highly recommend to a friend!
Fred H. via Google
He filed for eviction and knew that our name was deliberately misspelled...ultimately asked for a dismissal of his own case which he frivolously brought against us.
Ronald via Google
My wife came to this company first...I feel like they are biased...I would recommend staying far away from this shady law firm.
Nathan D. via Google