800 North Lynndale Drive, Appleton, WI 54914, United States

Herrling Clark Law Firm, Ltd. is a personal injury and wrongful death practice headquartered at 800 North Lynndale Drive in Appleton, Wisconsin. The firm was founded in 1959 by Don Herrling in downtown Appleton on the belief that residents of...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Herrling Clark Law Firm's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Herrling Clark Law Firm

Herrling Clark Law Firm, Ltd. is a Personal Injury and Wrongful Death practice headquartered at 800 North Lynndale Drive in Appleton, Wisconsin. The firm was founded in 1959 by Don Herrling in downtown Appleton on the belief that residents of the Fox Valley deserved top-tier legal counsel close to home, and it has now represented clients across Northeast Wisconsin for more than six decades.

Today the firm fields 17 practicing attorneys and operates four offices, with the Appleton headquarters supported by appointment-only locations in Green Bay, Oshkosh, and Waupaca. While its work spans family law, business and commercial law, real estate, municipal law, and probate, the firm is best known for catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation arising from auto, trucking, pedestrian, and construction-site accidents, as well as Product Liability and nursing home neglect.

That reputation is anchored by attorneys such as Kevin Lonergan, a board-certified civil trial specialist, past president of the Wisconsin Association for Justice, and recipient of its Trial Lawyer of the Year award, and senior partner John D. Claypool, named among the Top 50 lawyers in Wisconsin. Multiple Herrling Clark attorneys carry annual Super Lawyers recognition, reflecting a courtroom-tested approach to representing injured clients and grieving families.

Independent analysis · Public records

Herrling Clark Law Firm: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
88 / 100
Excellent

What is the reputation and track record of Herrling Clark Law Firm?

Herrling Clark Law Firm earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 88/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.5-star client rating. Founded in Appleton in 1959, the firm is anchored by Kevin Lonergan, admitted in Wisconsin in 1979 and a Board-Certified Civil Trial Specialist through the National Board of Trial Advocacy. Named his association's Trial Lawyer of the Year in 2014, he argued a unanimous personal-injury ruling before the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

Herrling Clark Law Firm — LawyerUp.Network Score 88/100

Reputation & results

83 / 100
  • 4.5★ · 88 reviews Client rating
  • Argued before the Wisconsin Supreme Court in Belding v. Demoulin, 2014 WI 8 (unanimous UM-stacking ruling) Track record Lead attorney argued for the trial-lawyers' amicus committee in a unanimous Wisconsin Supreme Court decision allowing stacking of uninsured-motorist coverage.

Experience

95 / 100
  • 47+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead attorney Kevin Lonergan admitted to the Wisconsin bar in 1979 (bar #1011310).
  • Active, good standing — no public discipline found Bar standing No public disciplinary record located in Wisconsin attorney-regulation listings.

Recognition

91 / 100
  • Board-certified Civil Trial Specialist (National Board of Trial Advocacy) Board certification NBTA is the oldest ABA-accredited attorney board-certifying agency.
  • ABOTA fellow (invitation-only); Past Pres. WI Academy of Trial Lawyers; Past Chair, State Bar Litigation Section Selective fellowship & bar leadership American Board of Trial Advocates membership is invitation-only; also past president of the Outagamie County Bar Association.
  • Named state Trial Lawyer of the Year (2014) — 15th honoree in the association's ~70-year history Peer recognition Wisconsin Association for Justice 'Trial Lawyer of the Year'; only 15 attorneys had received it in the group's nearly 70-year history.

Credentials

Education

JD, University of Wisconsin Law School

Bar Admissions

Admitted in WI

Professional Associations

Wisconsin Academy of Trial Lawyers (Past President) State Bar of Wisconsin Litigation Section (Past Chair) Wisconsin Association for Justice American Association for Justice Wisconsin Law Foundation Fellow
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Herrling Clark Law Firm

Last update: June 3, 2026

4.5
Based on 88 reviews (via Google)

Herrling Clark Law Firm earns consistent praise from clients across personal injury and family law, with reviewers frequently naming the specific attorney who handled their matter. Auto-accident clients credit John Claypool and his staff with putting them at ease "from the moment we walked in the door" and handling the paperwork so they could focus on recovering.

Several reviews highlight the firm's family-law and elder-focused work. Attorney Katelyn Sandfort is described as professional yet "gentle, kind and compassionate" in securing a good outcome for an elderly client, while attorney Elizabeth Scott earns thanks for steady, clear communication and quick responses during a difficult family matter.

Across the board, clients describe the firm as experienced, knowledgeable, and trustworthy, citing successful resolutions and attentive staff who keep them informed. With a 4.5-star average across 88 reviews, Herrling Clark is regularly recommended by clients who say they would return if they ever needed a lawyer again.

Responsiveness 4.5/5
Expertise 4.7/5
Transparency on fees 4.5/5
Case outcomes 4.6/5

Recent client quotes

John Claypool and his staff put us at ease from the moment we walked in the door till it was settled... They are very experienced and knowledgeable in what they do.
Barb L. via Google
Attorney Scott's steady approach, clear communication, and grounded professionalism brought a sense of peace... She was always quick to respond and made sure I understood each step.
Amber J. via Google
Attorney Sandfort and her team delivered a great outcome for my elderly mom! She was very professional, yet was very gentle, kind and compassionate.
Jody Z. via Google