Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson

Is this your firm? Claim it for free

802 SW C Avenue, Lawton, OK 73501

Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson, P.C. is the oldest law firm in Lawton and the Fort Sill area, tracing its roots to 1945 when W.W. Godlove opened his practice. For three generations the firm has served clients throughout Comanche...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson

Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson, P.C. is the oldest law firm in Lawton and the Fort Sill area, tracing its roots to 1945 when W.W. Godlove opened his practice. For three generations the firm has served clients throughout Comanche County and southwest Oklahoma, building a reputation that spans criminal defense, Family Law, business, and estate matters.

The firm's criminal defense work is led by Evan D. Watson, a former Comanche County Assistant District Attorney who now defends the accused in state and federal court. His courtroom background as a former prosecutor gives clients insight into how the other side builds a case, and he was named to Super Lawyers Rising Stars for criminal defense in 2023 and 2024. Partner J. Blake Dutcher, Jr. adds decades of experience, including service as a JAG officer who handled courts-martial at Fort Sill.

From its office at 802 SW C Avenue, the firm represents residents, service members, and families across the region facing misdemeanor and felony charges, including drug, DUI, and related offenses. Several of its attorneys have held leadership posts in the Comanche County and Oklahoma Bar Associations.

Independent analysis · Public records

Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
79 / 100
Strong

What is the reputation and track record of Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson?

Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 79/100 (Strong), based on public records and client feedback, with a 3.8-star client rating. Founded in 1945, it is the oldest law firm in Lawton and the Fort Sill area. Lead attorney Michael C. Mayhall, admitted in 1975, served as Vice President of the Oklahoma Bar Association and president of its Bar Foundation.

Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson — LawyerUp.Network Score 79/100

Reputation & results

72 / 100
  • 3.8★ · 11 reviews Client rating
  • Counsel of record in published OK Court of Civil Appeals cases Reported appellate decisions J. Blake Dutcher, Jr. served as counsel in Superior Supply Co. v. Torres, 1995 OK CIV APP 18 (900 P.2d 1005), Mariano v. Mariano, 2005 OK CIV APP 77, and 1414 Partnership v. Taveau, 1991 OK CIV APP 77.
  • State and federal court trial and appellate experience Trial & appellate practice Lead litigator briefed and argued appellate cases in both Oklahoma state and federal courts.

Experience

87 / 100
  • 50+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead attorney Michael C. Mayhall admitted to the Oklahoma Bar in 1975.
  • Founded 1945 — area's oldest firm Firm established Lawton/Ft. Sill's oldest law firm, founded by W.W. Godlove in 1945; continuous practice in Southwest Oklahoma.
  • Active, good standing — no public discipline found Bar standing

Recognition

83 / 100
  • OBA Vice President & Board of Governors; Bar Foundation President State bar leadership Michael C. Mayhall: Oklahoma Bar Association Board of Governors (1990-92), Vice President (1998), and President of the Oklahoma Bar Foundation Board of Trustees.
  • Multiple Comanche County Bar Association presidents County bar leadership Firm attorneys have served as Comanche County Bar Association president — Michael Mayhall (1988), J. Blake Dutcher, and Evan D. Watson (2022).

Credentials

Education

JD, University of Oklahoma College of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in OK

Professional Associations

Oklahoma Bar Association Oklahoma Bar Foundation Comanche County Bar Association
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson

Last update: May 28, 2026

3.8
Based on 11 reviews (via Google)

Godlove, Mayhall, Dutcher, Rabon & Watson is Lawton's long-established, multi-practice firm, and its reviews reflect a range of experiences across criminal, civil, probate, adoption, and family matters. Several clients praise specific attorneys, including Austin Rabon, who is also a CPA, and attorney Watson, who handled a stepparent adoption that one reviewer said he took care to do correctly.

Other reviewers report communication problems. One described an unresponsive divorce matter in which calls went unreturned over an extended period, and another recounted a rude phone interaction with office staff. With a modest number of public reviews, the feedback is genuinely split between clients who value the firm's experience and those who felt let down on follow-through.

Prospective clients will find a firm with deep local roots and capable individual attorneys, alongside responsiveness concerns that some reviewers raised.

Responsiveness 3.3/5
Expertise 3.9/5
Transparency on fees 3.4/5
Case outcomes 3.6/5

Recent client quotes

Dealt with one incredible attorney by the name of Austin Raybon who is also an experienced CPA. This guy can work for your best interest beyond doubt! They do civil, criminal, probate and more!
Verified client via Google
Had a good experience using Watson as an attorney to aid my husband in adopting my son. It took a bit longer than expected but that was because he wanted to be careful it was done right. He was very kind and fair!
Verified client via Google
I called Mr. Dutcher over and over to see what the next step would be. He was always busy or out of town. The secretary would tell me he would call me back but he never did.
Heather M. via Google