135 Delaware Avenue, Suite 405, Buffalo, NY 14202, United States
Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri is a Buffalo law firm that has concentrated on workers' compensation and Social Security disability since Stephen M. Gielowski founded it in 1993. The office sits in downtown Buffalo at 135 Delaware Avenue, Suite 405, and...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri
Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri is a Buffalo law firm that has concentrated on Workers' Compensation and Social Security Disability since Stephen M. Gielowski founded it in 1993. The office sits in downtown Buffalo at 135 Delaware Avenue, Suite 405, and represents injured workers across Western New York, handling claims filed in both the Buffalo and Rochester Workers' Compensation Board districts.
Managing partner John R. Federice was admitted to the New York bar in 1997 and carries firsthand knowledge of the insurer side of these disputes, having spent 2001 to 2004 as in-house counsel for Royal Insurance before returning to full-time claimant work. Partner Joseph A. Caligiuri, admitted in 1998, came to the practice after working as a claims associate at Cigna Property & Casualty, while James P. Wistner, a former Sullivan County assistant district attorney, joined the litigation team in 2017. Gielowski, now of counsel, previously served as past president of the Erie County Bar Association's Workers' Compensation Committee.
The attorneys guide clients through hearings, medical evidence disputes, and reduced-earnings and permanency awards, and they carry contested matters through the appellate level when a Board decision warrants review. The firm pairs that comp focus with Social Security disability and Personal Injury representation, offering injured workers in the Buffalo area a single team for overlapping benefit claims.
Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri?
Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 81/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.1-star client rating. The Buffalo firm has concentrated on workers' compensation and Social Security disability since 1993, and managing partner John R. Federice, admitted in New York in 1997, carries insurer-side experience that clients say sharpens his handling of long-running claims.
Reputation & results
- 4.1★ · 52 reviews Client rating
- Handles workers' compensation litigation through the appellate level Appellate practice Firm founder handled matters through the NY Court of Appeals
Experience
- Admitted 1997 (29 years) Years licensed Managing partner John R. Federice; NY registration no. 2791846
- Former in-house counsel for Royal Insurance (2001-2004) Insurance-defense background Perspective on how carriers evaluate and defend claims
Credentials
What Clients Say
What clients say about Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri
Last update: July 30, 2026
Gielowski, Federice & Caligiuri holds a 4.1-star aggregate across roughly 52 reviews, with workers' compensation clients providing the most detailed feedback. Managing partner John Federice is named in review after review for patiently walking clients through the comp process, returning calls promptly, and staying with cases that stretch on for years.
Reviewers also credit attorney James Wistner, whom Federice brought onto their matters, for honest, knowledgeable handling and steady communication. The recurring theme is guidance through an unfamiliar system: clients describe attorneys who explain each step, answer frequent questions, and treat them with respect during long-running claims.
The feedback reflects a firm whose comp-focused attorneys are valued for accessibility and follow-through on the kind of drawn-out benefit disputes that define this practice area.
Recent client quotes
He took the time to explain each step of the process, answered my questions promptly, and kept me informed throughout.
John Federice has been working with me for existing comp case for about 4 years now. He always answers my questions and helps me to understand this whole process.
Similar Attorneys
Penar Law
Penar Law, formally the Law Office of Gary R. Penar, P.S., is a Spokane Valley firm that handles Social Security…
View profile
Gingras Thomsen & Wachs – Madison
Gingras, Thomsen & Wachs has represented injured and wronged individuals across Wisconsin for over four decades, recovering more than $200…
View profile
Gardner & Rans
Gardner & Rans P.C. represents injured drivers, passengers, and motorcyclists across the South Bend, Mishawaka, Granger, Elkhart, and La Porte…
View profile