141 N Broadway, Lexington, KY 40507, United States

Garmer & Prather is a plaintiff-side trial firm based in the Opera House Office Building at 141 N Broadway in downtown Lexington, Kentucky. Founded in 1984 by trial lawyer William R. "Bill" Garmer, the practice concentrates on catastrophic injury and...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Garmer & Prather's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Garmer & Prather

Garmer & Prather is a plaintiff-side trial firm based in the Opera House Office Building at 141 N Broadway in downtown Lexington, Kentucky. Founded in 1984 by trial lawyer William R. "Bill" Garmer, the practice concentrates on catastrophic injury and death cases, including Nursing Home Abuse and neglect, Medical Malpractice, trucking collisions, products liability, and wrongful death claims across the Commonwealth.

The firm reports recovering more than $80 million in verdicts and settlements since 2009. Among its notable results, it helped the Kentucky Attorney General secure a $25 million settlement with Merck over the marketing of the drug Vioxx, approved by the Franklin Circuit Court in 2013. Bill Garmer, a 1975 graduate of the University of Kentucky College of Law, served as president of both the Kentucky Bar Association and the Kentucky Justice Association and was inducted into the College of Law Hall of Fame in 2014.

Founding member Jerome P. Prather now leads the practice. A 2006 University of Kentucky College of Law graduate and Vanderbilt economics and political science double major, Prather is a Fellow of the Litigation Counsel of America, a Life Fellow of the Kentucky Bar Foundation, and a governor of the Kentucky Justice Association. He earned a 2026 "Lawyer of the Year" honor for Lexington Personal Injury litigation from a leading peer-review publication.

Independent analysis · Public records

Garmer & Prather: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
82 / 100
Excellent

What is the reputation and track record of Garmer & Prather?

Garmer & Prather earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 82/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.2-star client rating. The Lexington trial firm, founded in 1984, has recovered more than $80 million since 2009, including a $25 million Merck Vioxx settlement. Now led by Jerome Prather, a Litigation Counsel of America Fellow, it focuses on catastrophic injury and nursing-home cases.

Garmer & Prather — LawyerUp.Network Score 82/100

Reputation & results

78 / 100
  • 4.2★ · 10 reviews Client rating
  • $80M+ in verdicts and settlements since 2009; $25M Merck Vioxx settlement (2013) Verifiable results $25M Vioxx settlement corroborated by Merck SEC filings.

Experience

  • 20 years Years in practice Jerome P. Prather admitted to the Kentucky bar in 2006; firm founded 1984.
  • Active; no public discipline located License standing
  • University of Kentucky College of Law, J.D. 2006 Law school B.A. Vanderbilt, cum laude.

Recognition

95 / 100
  • Fellow, Litigation Counsel of America; Life Fellow, Kentucky Bar Foundation; Governor, Kentucky Justice Association Fellowships & bar leadership Co-founder William Garmer served as president of the Kentucky Bar Association and was inducted into the UK College of Law Hall of Fame.
  • Peer-recognized Lawyer of the Year (2026); statewide Top-50 recognition Peer recognition Peer-review recognition for Lexington personal injury litigation.

Credentials

Education

JD, University of Kentucky College of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in KY

Professional Associations

Litigation Counsel of America (Fellow) Kentucky Bar Foundation (Life Fellow) Kentucky Justice Association American Association for Justice American Bar Association Fayette County Bar Association
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Garmer & Prather

Last update: July 11, 2026

4.2
Based on 10 reviews (via Google)

Garmer & Prather holds a 4.2-star average across 10 reviews for its plaintiff-side injury practice. Clients and even a referring out-of-state attorney describe Jerome 'Jay' Prather as organized, methodical, and effective — one recounts a Kentucky federal jury verdict worth more than three times the trucking insurer's last offer.

Reviewers praise the support team, singling out Shannon Williams, and describe a firm that is approachable yet firm when it counts. The feedback centers on serious injury and trucking cases, with clients noting professionalism and a commitment to pursuing every avenue to resolution.

Responsiveness 4.4/5
Expertise 4.6/5
Transparency on fees 4.2/5
Case outcomes 4.5/5

Recent client quotes

Jay Prather took the case to jury trial in the Kentucky federal courts and obtained a jury verdict of over 3 times the last offer by the trucking company insurer.
Jeff S. via Google
Jay was very organized and had an easily understood framework for my case.
Seth A. via Google