1101 N. Broadway Avenue, Suite 102, Oklahoma City, OK 73103, United States

Fulmer Sill is an Oklahoma City plaintiffs' firm founded in 2014 by Simone Fulmer Gaus and Matthew J. Sill, with James D. Sill also a name partner. Its work has two sides. In Oklahoma it takes catastrophic personal injury cases,...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Fulmer Sill's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Fulmer Sill

Fulmer Sill is an Oklahoma City plaintiffs' firm founded in 2014 by Simone Fulmer Gaus and Matthew J. Sill, with James D. Sill also a name partner. Its work has two sides. In Oklahoma it takes catastrophic Personal Injury cases, including truck and car crashes, Wrongful Death and insurance bad faith. Nationwide it handles pharmaceutical, medical device and consumer litigation. The firm reports more than $1 billion recovered for clients, including an $11 million settlement for an oilfield worker and his passenger, hurt when an impaired truck driver turned in front of their vehicle, and a $5.2 million verdict for an injured pedestrian.

Matthew Sill leads the mass tort and Class Action work. He previously served on the American Association for Justice Board of Governors. In 2011 a federal court in the Eastern District of Kentucky appointed him to the Plaintiffs' Executive Committee in the Darvocet and Darvon multidistrict litigation. In 2020 he was counsel for an Oklahoma hospital in the Tenth Circuit's published decision in the Genentech Herceptin MDL. The firm's current dockets include GLP-1 diabetes and weight-loss drugs, Depo-Provera, Camp Lejeune water contamination, Paraquat, PFAS exposure, hip implants and data breaches. It also brings opioid claims for cities, counties and tribes.

Simone Fulmer Gaus graduated from the University of Oklahoma College of Law in 1996 and is a past president of the Oklahoma Association for Justice. She concentrates on insurance coverage and bad faith disputes. The firm's 12 attorneys work from offices on North Broadway in Oklahoma City and on North Eastern Avenue in Edmond, and take cases throughout Oklahoma.

Independent analysis · Public records

Fulmer Sill: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
89 / 100
Excellent

What is the reputation and track record of Fulmer Sill?

Fulmer Sill holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 89/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.9-star client rating. In 2011 a federal court appointed co-founder Matthew J. Sill to the Plaintiffs' Executive Committee of the Darvocet and Darvon multidistrict litigation. The Oklahoma City firm pairs that national mass tort work with catastrophic injury cases at home, including a reported $5.2 million verdict for an injured pedestrian.

Fulmer Sill — LawyerUp.Network Score 89/100

Reputation & results

90 / 100
  • 4.9★ · 145 reviews Client rating
  • Counsel in published 10th Cir. decision (2020) Appellate work Counsel for appellant Comanche County Memorial Hospital in In re MDL 2700 Genentech Herceptin; the Tenth Circuit reversed summary judgment for Genentech and remanded.

Experience

83 / 100
  • 20+ yrs (J.D. 2005) Years licensed Law degree 2005. The firm bio does not give an Oklahoma admission year, and the Oklahoma bar member directory requires a login, so this was not checked against an official record.
  • Good standing in Missouri (admitted 2018) Bar standing Missouri record only. The Oklahoma registry could not be checked (member login), so no standing claim is made for Oklahoma.

Recognition

95 / 100
  • Plaintiffs' Executive Committee, MDL 2226 (Darvocet/Darvon) Court-appointed MDL leadership Named to the PEC (then at Sill & Medley, Edmond) in the federal multidistrict litigation over propoxyphene products.
  • Former AAJ Board of Governors; OAJ Executive Committee Trial-bar leadership Elected roles in the American and Oklahoma Associations for Justice.
  • Peer-recognized plaintiff consumer lawyer, 2022-2025 Peer recognition National peer list for plaintiff consumer lawyers, four consecutive years.

Credentials

Education

JD, Whittier Law School

Bar Admissions

Admitted in OK Admitted in MO

Professional Associations

Oklahoma Association for Justice (Executive Committee, Board of Directors) American Association for Justice (former Board of Governors)
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Fulmer Sill

Last update: October 9, 2026

4.9
Based on 145 reviews (via Google)

Fulmer Sill averages 4.9 stars across 145 Google reviews, a large sample dominated by injury clients after car wrecks and surgeries. Reviewers repeatedly say the team treated them as people rather than case numbers and handled the insurance companies on their behalf.

Proactive updates are the strongest theme: one client injured in an October 2025 wreck says she never had to call or text for an update. Attorney Jacob Rowe and staff members including Amanda, Lauren and Ashley Nelson are named for going above and beyond, and clients describe the firm as working as a coordinated team.

Several reviewers add that they plan to refer friends and family based on how their cases were handled.

Responsiveness 5.0/5
Expertise 4.8/5
Transparency on fees 4.9/5
Case outcomes 4.8/5

Recent client quotes

I have never had to text or call for an update because they were on top of everything.
Rachel M. via Google
From the very beginning, they treated us like people, not just another case or number.
Michael M. via Google
Jacob Rowe and the entire staff went above and beyond throughout my case.
Amy G. via Google
View more Google reviews