1507 Monroe Avenue, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
DeCarolis Defense, formerly known as Nobles & DeCarolis, is a Rochester, New York criminal defense firm working from 1507 Monroe Avenue. Its caseload runs from DWI, drug and weapons charges to violent felonies in state and federal court, and the...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout DeCarolis Defense
DeCarolis Defense, formerly known as Nobles & DeCarolis, is a Rochester, New York criminal defense firm working from 1507 Monroe Avenue. Its caseload runs from DWI, drug and weapons charges to violent felonies in state and federal court, and the firm added a Personal Injury practice in 2016. Former partner James Nobles was hired in late 2025 as a prosecutor for the Ontario County District Attorney's Office, and the practice now carries Brian DeCarolis's name alone.
DeCarolis graduated from Albany Law School in 2005 and was admitted to the New York bar in 2006, when he joined the Monroe County District Attorney's Office. He served there as a senior assistant district attorney in the Violent Felony Bureau before opening a solo defense practice in 2010, then partnered with Nobles in 2015. The Daily Record, Rochester's legal newspaper, named him to its 2011 class of Up & Coming Attorneys. He was counsel of record when the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, in 2017 unanimously dismissed the prosecution's appeal of a Monroe County Court order dismissing a second-degree murder charge after a deadlocked jury trial.
For white-collar matters, the firm defends allegations including wire, mail and bank fraud, money laundering, embezzlement, tax fraud, identity theft, forgery, computer tampering, and insurance and mortgage fraud, along with conspiracy and racketeering charges. It also represents doctors, dentists, nurses, teachers and other licensed professionals facing criminal accusations, students charged with offenses, and people who learn they are under investigation before any charge is filed.
DeCarolis Defense: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of DeCarolis Defense?
DeCarolis Defense holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 83/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.8-star client rating. In 2017 New York's Appellate Division unanimously dismissed the prosecution's appeal of a trial court order that had thrown out a murder charge against Brian DeCarolis's client; DeCarolis, a former Monroe County prosecutor admitted in 2006, was named a 2011 Up & Coming Attorney by The Daily Record.
Reputation & results
- 4.8★ · 35 reviews Client rating
- Murder charge dismissed; prosecution appeal dismissed (4th Dept., 2017) Track record Counsel of record in People v Tan (App. Div. 4th Dept., Mar. 31, 2017): the court unanimously dismissed the prosecution's appeal of a 2015 Monroe County Court trial order dismissing a second-degree murder charge, leaving in place a dismissal that bars retrial.
Experience
- 20 yrs licensed Years licensed Admitted to the New York bar in 2006 (Fourth Judicial Department).
- Registered in New York, reg. #4361374 Bar registration Official state attorney registration record: admitted 2006, Fourth Judicial Department, Albany Law School.
- Monroe County ADA, 2006-2010 Former prosecutor Served as a senior assistant district attorney in the Violent Felony Bureau before opening a defense practice in 2010.
Recognition
- The Daily Record honoree, 2011 Up & Coming Attorney Named to the Rochester legal newspaper's 2011 class of Up & Coming Attorneys.
- Peer-recognized criminal trial lawyer, 2015-2021 Peer recognition Listed each year from 2015 through 2021 on a national top-100 roster of New York criminal trial lawyers.
- Chair, Monroe County Lawyer Referral Program Bar service Chair since 2013; member of the Monroe County Bar Association and the New York State Defenders Association since 2011.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about DeCarolis Defense
Last update: September 24, 2026
DeCarolis Defense holds a 4.8-star average across 35 reviews. Clients of the Rochester criminal defense practice describe Brian DeCarolis as knowledgeable, thorough and straightforward, and several credit him with the best outcome they could have hoped for, including in a firearm case; some also point to his earlier years as a prosecutor.
Communication draws specific praise: reviewers say calls were returned the same day, emails were answered right away and news was passed along as it developed. Several value his candor, noting that he gave unvarnished advice rather than selling them a story.
One detailed one-star review from a client with a more serious matter takes the opposite view, faulting a lack of preparation and strategy discussion after a substantial retainer, as well as a declined court appearance; that reviewer praised only the legal assistant's responsiveness.
Recent client quotes
Brian represented me on two separate cases and if there was ever a question he would provide an answer promptly. My phone calls were always returned before the end day.
He was straightforward, incredibly professional and answered any and all questions helping ease my mind whilst making sure I was aware of every aspect of my case.
Thanks to his guidance, I got a positive outcome.
Similar Attorneys
Omega Law Group
Omega Law Group represents injured Californians from its office on Sunset Boulevard in West Hollywood, concentrating on auto, truck, motorcycle,…
View profile
Tucker Law Group PLLC
Tucker Law Group specializes in the areas of the Defense Base Act and the Longshore and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act,…
View profile
Goldstein, Rubinton, Goldstein & DiFazio
Goldstein, Rubinton, Goldstein & DiFazio is a Huntington, New York law firm that has served clients across Long Island since…
View profile