Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney

Is this your firm? Claim it for free

2445 Capitol Street, Suite 115, Fresno, CA 93721, United States

Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney is a Fresno firm whose entire caseload sits on one side of the California workers' compensation system: injured employees. The practice handles work injury claims and Social Security Disability appeals only, and takes no...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney

Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney is a Fresno firm whose entire caseload sits on one side of the California Workers' Compensation system: injured employees. The practice handles work injury claims and Social Security Disability appeals only, and takes no defense-side work. Curtis A. Cole opened the practice in 1985 after two decades of comp work in Fresno dating back to the early 1960s; the firm name has grown to its present form as partners joined after his 2005 retirement.

Two attorneys carry the docket, and both are certified by the State Bar of California as specialists in workers' compensation law. Joseph G. O'Keefe was admitted in 1996, studied at San Joaquin College of Law after a Fresno State degree in journalism and business, and has served as president of the Central Valley chapter of the California Applicants' Attorneys Association. Rachel G. Mahoney, admitted in 2012, became a third-generation partner at the firm and holds the same State Bar specialist certification.

Ten support staff back the two attorneys, including a bilingual legal secretary who takes Spanish-speaking clients through the claim process. The firm works from a single downtown office on Capitol Street, roughly five minutes from the Fresno district office of the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board, and serves claimants across the Central Valley. Consultations are free and cases are handled on a contingency basis, with office hours Monday through Friday, 8am to 5pm.

Independent analysis · Public records

Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
86 / 100
Excellent

What is the reputation and track record of Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney?

Cole Fisher Cole O’Keefe + Mahoney holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 86/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.4-star client rating. Both practising attorneys are certified by the State Bar of California as workers compensation specialists, and both licences are active with no public discipline. The Fresno practice has represented injured workers continuously since 1985 and takes no defence-side work at all.

Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney — LawyerUp.Network Score 86/100

Reputation & results

81 / 100
  • 4.4★ · 36 reviews Client rating
  • Active, no public discipline License standing State Bar license status, disciplinary and administrative history table shows Active with no discipline or administrative actions since admission.

Experience

91 / 100
  • 29 years (admitted 1996) Years licensed Lead partner Joseph G. O'Keefe, California Bar #184862, admitted 12/9/1996.
  • Continuous practice since 1985 Firm tenure in Fresno Founded by Curtis A. Cole in 1985; he retired in 2005 and the firm name has grown to its present form as partners joined since.

Recognition

89 / 100
  • Certified Specialist, Workers' Compensation Law (State Bar of California) Board certification Certification by the State Bar of California Board of Legal Specialization, held by a small fraction of California licensees.
  • Both practising attorneys are certified workers' compensation specialists Certified specialists on staff Joseph G. O'Keefe (#184862) and Rachel G. Mahoney (#283129, admitted 6/6/2012) each carry the State Bar certification; both licenses Active with no discipline.
  • Past President, Central Valley Chapter, California Applicants' Attorneys Association Bar leadership Also a member of the California Lawyers Association Workers' Compensation Section per the State Bar profile.

Credentials

Education

JD, San Joaquin College of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in CA

Professional Associations

California Applicants' Attorneys Association (CAAA) California Lawyers Association — Workers' Compensation Section National Association of Social Security Representatives Fresno County Bar Association
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Cole Fisher Cole O’Keefe + Mahoney

Last update: September 23, 2026

4.4
Based on 36 reviews (via Google)

Feedback on Cole Fisher Cole O'Keefe + Mahoney splits along a clear line: clients who worked directly with attorney Joseph O'Keefe describe a plain-spoken, realistic advocate, while the firm's lower ratings center on communication and case handling rather than on legal judgment. O'Keefe is repeatedly described as direct about what a workers' compensation claim is worth and what the process involves, with one reviewer noting he does not sugarcoat a weak position and keeps pushing on a small case an employer is contesting.

The criticism is specific. One reviewer reports calling repeatedly over a week without a return call at the inquiry stage. Another describes a back-injury claim largely delegated to a legal assistant, learning about a rejected offer after the fact and feeling under-informed at a settlement conference. Both of those accounts concern an attorney who is no longer with the practice, which now consists of O'Keefe and Rachel Mahoney.

Positive reviews mention front-desk staff as courteous and consultations as concise and easy to follow, with the process explained in terms a claimant can act on. For a firm that takes only injured-worker and disability claimants, the pattern suggests the substantive work draws confidence while intake responsiveness is the weaker point prospective clients should test early.

Responsiveness 3.9/5
Expertise 4.6/5
Transparency on fees 4.4/5
Case outcomes 4.2/5

Recent client quotes

Joseph was very direct, clear and helpful. He described the process of what we would be going through very concisely. Made everything easy to understand.
Verified client via Google
He has always been friendly and professional he doesn't sugarcoat my situation and lets me know exactly what to expect... Joe continues to fight for my rights.
Greg F. via Google
I've called at least more than twice in a week left information for a call back. Yet never received a call back.
Kami L. via Google
View more Google reviews