300 South State Street, 1st Floor, Syracuse, NY 13202, United States

Cambareri & Brenneck, PLLC is a Syracuse criminal defense firm formed in January 2021 by Stefano (Steve) Cambareri and Scott A. Brenneck, both former Onondaga County assistant district attorneys. Every lawyer on its roster has served in the Onondaga County...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Cambareri & Brenneck's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Cambareri & Brenneck

Cambareri & Brenneck, PLLC is a Syracuse criminal defense firm formed in January 2021 by Stefano (Steve) Cambareri and Scott A. Brenneck, both former Onondaga County assistant district attorneys. Every lawyer on its roster has served in the Onondaga County District Attorney's Office, and the firm works from a single office at 300 South State Street in downtown Syracuse, handling cases in Onondaga County courts and across Central and Upstate New York.

Cambareri, admitted in New York in 1990, spent nearly nine years as a prosecutor trying violent felony cases, then managed his earlier firm, Cambareri & Cambareri, LLP, from 1999. A magna cum laude graduate of Syracuse University College of Law, he has taught trial practice there as an adjunct, and in 2024 he was appointed to the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, the constitutional body that reviews misconduct complaints against judges. Brenneck, admitted in 2002, prosecuted assaults, robberies and weapons cases in the office's Felony Trial Unit before moving to the defense side.

Attorney Melissa K. Swartz, who worked in the same DA's office from 2014 to 2018, concentrates on trials, appeals and post-conviction work in state and federal courts, plus university disciplinary and Title IX matters. Together with attorney J. David Hammond, she helped secure the 2021 exoneration of Anthony Broadwater, whose 1982 rape conviction in the Alice Sebold case was vacated with the district attorney's support. The roster also includes former prosecutor Joe Centra and lists retired Appellate Division Justice John Centra as special counsel.

Day to day, the firm defends DWI and DWAI charges, drug possession, weapons, larceny and sex offenses, extreme risk protection order (ERPO) proceedings, federal charges and Traffic Tickets.

Independent analysis · Public records

Cambareri & Brenneck: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
85 / 100
Excellent

What is the reputation and track record of Cambareri & Brenneck?

Cambareri & Brenneck holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 85/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.7-star client rating. Its record includes the 2021 exoneration of Anthony Broadwater, which attorney Melissa K. Swartz helped secure. Founding partner Steve Cambareri, a former Onondaga County prosecutor admitted in New York in 1990, sits on the state Commission on Judicial Conduct and teaches trial practice at Syracuse Law.

Cambareri & Brenneck — LawyerUp.Network Score 85/100

Reputation & results

85 / 100
  • 4.7★ · 80 reviews Client rating
  • Broadwater exoneration (2021) Wrongful-conviction reversal Firm attorney Melissa K. Swartz, with J. David Hammond, won vacatur of Anthony Broadwater's 1982 rape conviction in the Alice Sebold case; the Onondaga County DA joined the motion

Experience

87 / 100
  • 36 yrs licensed Years licensed Founding partner Stefano (Steve) Cambareri, admitted in New York in 1990 (Fourth Department)
  • Currently registered in New York Bar registration Registered with the New York courts since 1990; next re-registration due 2028
  • Ex-Onondaga County assistant DA Former prosecutor Nearly nine years in the DA's office, trying violent felony cases, before entering private practice

Recognition

83 / 100
  • Member, NYS Commission on Judicial Conduct Judicial oversight role Appointed in 2024 by Assembly Minority Leader William A. Barclay; current term runs to March 31, 2029
  • Adjunct trial practice professor, Syracuse Law Law school faculty Teaches trial practice at his alma mater, Syracuse University College of Law (JD 1989, magna cum laude)

Credentials

Education

JD, Syracuse University College of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in NY

Professional Associations

New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Cambareri & Brenneck

Last update: September 24, 2026

4.7
Based on 80 reviews (via Google)

Cambareri & Brenneck holds a 4.7-star rating across 80 Google reviews, and most recent comments center on attorney Melissa Swartz. A family referred to her through the Onondaga County Bar Association credits her with a unanimous appellate win they had been told was unlikely, and another client describes nearly four years of work on a single case with constant check-ins.

Other reviewers say she kept them informed, resolved a sensitive matter quickly and quietly, and handled traffic tickets without requiring them to appear in court. Founding partner Steve Cambareri is praised by a client who calls him the best defense attorney in Central New York.

Responsiveness 4.9/5
Expertise 4.8/5
Transparency on fees 4.7/5
Case outcomes 4.9/5

Recent client quotes

Ms. Swartz led the charge in our matter to the NY Appeals Court and secured for us a unanimous (which was predicted by most as a highly unlikely) victory.
Brynetta H. via Google
She was able to get the outcome my wife needed quickly and quietly.
Andrew F. via Google
She communicated and checked in with me constantly over the time we worked together.
Daniel B. via Google
View more Google reviews