302 E Main St, Suite 202, Carnegie, PA 15106, United States
AlpernSchubert is a plaintiff-side litigation firm in Carnegie, just west of Pittsburgh, that has concentrated on civil lawsuits for more than 30 years. The practice centers on workers' compensation, personal injury and motor vehicle claims, insurance bad faith litigation, and...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout AlpernSchubert
AlpernSchubert is a plaintiff-side litigation firm in Carnegie, just west of Pittsburgh, that has concentrated on civil lawsuits for more than 30 years. The practice centers on Workers' Compensation, Personal Injury and motor vehicle claims, insurance bad faith litigation, and Social Security Disability, serving clients across Allegheny, Beaver, Butler, Erie, Washington and Westmoreland counties.
Three partners carry more than 100 years of combined practice between them. Richard J. Schubert has tried personal injury cases since his 1980 admission to the Pennsylvania bar, holds national civil trial certification first earned in 1999 and recertified in 2024, and led the statewide trial lawyers association as its president in 2003-2004. Lawrence R. Chaban, a University of Pittsburgh Law graduate and certified Pennsylvania workers' compensation specialist, was inducted as a Fellow of the College of Workers' Compensation Lawyers in 2013 and chairs the employee side of Pennsylvania's Workers' Compensation Advisory Council. David C. Brumfield rounds out the partnership with trial work in motor vehicle, bad faith and breach of contract matters.
For Social Security Disability claimants, the firm takes cases at any stage: assembling the initial application and supporting medical documentation, pushing back when a claim stalls, filing reconsideration requests, and appearing at appeal hearings. Because the same attorneys handle workers' compensation and short-term disability disputes with private insurers, overlapping claims are managed under one roof rather than referred out. Consultations are free, and the office works only for claimants, never for insurers or employers.
AlpernSchubert: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of AlpernSchubert?
AlpernSchubert holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 86/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.4-star client rating. Partner Lawrence R. Chaban chairs the employee representatives on Pennsylvania statutory Workers Compensation Advisory Council and is a Fellow of the College of Workers Compensation Lawyers. The Carnegie firm has taken only claimant-side work, never insurers or employers, for more than three decades.
Reputation & results
- 4.4★ · 14 reviews Client rating
- George F. Douglas Amicus Curiae Award (2007), Milton D. Rosenberg Award (2018), Irvin Stander Memorial Award (2021) Bar association awards Awards conferred by the state trial-lawyer bar and workers' compensation bar, not by a paid listing service.
Experience
- 46 years (Pennsylvania, 1980) Years licensed Partners Richard J. Schubert and Lawrence R. Chaban were both admitted in Pennsylvania in 1980; founding partner Charles H. Alpern, admitted 1970, is now of counsel.
- W.D. Pa. plus the Third, Fourth and Sixth Circuit Courts of Appeals Federal court admissions Admissions listed across the two founding partners.
Recognition
- Fellow, College of Workers' Compensation Lawyers Invitation-only fellowship Invitation-only national college of workers compensation attorneys; partner Lawrence R. Chaban appears in its published Directory of Fellows. The 2013 induction year is firm-reported.
- Employee-representative Chairman, Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Advisory Council State advisory council chairmanship Statutory eight-member council under the Pennsylvania Workers' Compensation Act, appointed seat.
- Past president of the statewide trial lawyers association (2003-2004) and of the Western Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association (1993-1994) Bar association leadership Partners have also chaired the state association's workers' compensation section and amicus committee and served as a Pennsylvania Bar Association zone governor.
- National civil trial specialist certification (first certified 1999, recertified 2024) and Pennsylvania certified workers' compensation law specialist Board certification Certifying board's own online directory could not be loaded, so this is scored conservatively.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about AlpernSchubert
Last update: September 23, 2026
AlpernSchubert's client feedback centers on insurance disputes, and attorney David C. Brumfield draws both the strongest praise and the sharpest criticism in the set. Two clients describe him taking over a stalled claim after they had spent weeks getting nowhere with an insurer, setting clear expectations, and then keeping them updated until the carrier paid. One writes that Brumfield negotiated as though the outcome were his own family's; another that after a month of wasted effort, the words 'I'll handle it from here' turned out to be accurate.
A dissenting review from a different client alleges the opposite on the same attorney: poor email follow-up, slow evidence-gathering and pressure to settle. Another reviewer reports not being able to reach anyone by phone for an initial consultation at all. That sits oddly against a separate account of calling once and being put straight through to an attorney for a free fifteen-minute consultation that explained what the insurer was likely doing and what steps to take before hiring anyone.
With a small review count, no single account should be weighted too heavily, but the pattern is legible: when the firm engages, clients describe substantive advocacy against insurers and concrete guidance; the variance sits in reach-through at the front end and in follow-up communication on longer files. Asking at intake who will handle the file and how updates are delivered would address most of what the critical reviews describe.
Recent client quotes
Not only did Dave do an amazing job in setting expectations with me, he said "I'll handle it from here", and he meant it! ... he kept me updated throughout the process in getting the insurance company to reimburse me!
The attorney listened carefully, explained what was likely happening behind the scenes with my insurance company, and gave me concrete steps I could take on my own before engaging legal counsel.
Couldn't even get a consult or speak to someone over the phone for literally what their website says they do.
Similar Attorneys
Dunnam & Dunnam
Dunnam & Dunnam, L.L.P. is a full-service law firm in Waco, Texas that has served Central Texas families and businesses…
View profile
Trapani Law Firm
Trapani Law Firm, LLC is an Allentown personal injury practice founded by attorney Matthew Trapani, with its office at 133…
View profile
Costanzo Law Firm
Costanzo Law Firm is a plaintiff-side employment practice based in downtown San Jose at 111 W. St. John Street, serving…
View profile