Monticello, Minnesota 55362, United States
We at Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson provide big firm service with small-town values. Our clients come to us because of our experience, knowledge, experience, track record in and out of the courtroom, and our reputation for integrity and client...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson, PLC
We at Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson provide big firm service with small-town values. Our clients come to us because of our experience, knowledge, experience, track record in and out of the courtroom, and our reputation for integrity and client satisfaction. We have deep roots in the community.
Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson, PLC: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson, PLC?
Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson, PLC holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 78/100 (Strong), based on public records and client feedback, with a 3.7-star client rating. Serving Minnesota since 1968, this Monticello firm carries more than five decades of continuous practice. Named partner Jacob T. Erickson was admitted to the Minnesota bar in 2003, and the firm staffs MSBA Certified Legal Specialists in real property and labor and employment, a designation held by roughly 3% of Minnesota attorneys.
Reputation & results
- 3.7★ · 40 reviews Client rating
Experience
- 23+ yrs licensed Years licensed (lead attorney) Jacob T. Erickson, named partner — admitted to the Minnesota bar in 2003.
- Active, good standing — no public discipline Bar standing Verifiable via the Minnesota Lawyer Registration Office (MARS) and the Office of Lawyers Professional Responsibility.
- Serving Minnesota since 1968 Firm established Long-established Monticello firm; over five decades of continuous practice.
Recognition
- MSBA Certified Specialists on staff (Real Property; Labor & Employment) State-bar Certified Legal Specialist Minnesota State Bar Association Certified Specialist — a designation held by roughly 3% of Minnesota attorneys, requiring exam and peer review.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about Smith, Paulson, O’Donnell & Erickson, PLC
Last update: May 21, 2026
Reviews of Smith, Paulson, O'Donnell & Erickson paint a sharply divided picture that hinges on which attorney handles the case. Clients of Jacob (Jacobo) Erickson describe a tenacious, deeply experienced advocate who has worked cases spanning local courts, federal court, Hague Convention matters, and criminal defense. Multiple reviewers credit him with cleaning up complex, high-conflict family situations after other lawyers declined or fumbled their cases, and they single out fast email replies, phone accessibility, and strategic planning sessions where he walks clients through the plan of action.
The negative reviews involve different attorneys at the firm and raise consistent operational concerns: slow service after retainers were paid, cryptic or absent status updates, and outcomes that diverged sharply from what clients were told to expect. One reviewer describes a contract-cancellation matter where notice was never served on the defendant despite weeks of opportunity, costing the client thousands they were legally entitled to plus the legal bill. A second reviewer recounts hiring an attorney for what was pitched as an easy dismissal and instead being blindsided at a hearing by a plea deal worked out with the prosecutor, followed by weeks of being ghosted while continuing to pay $500-a-month installments.
Practice areas surfacing in the reviews include criminal defense, family and custody disputes (including international/Hague matters), appeals, and contract enforcement. Prospective clients reading these reviews should note that experience appears to vary significantly attorney-by-attorney within the firm, and that fee disputes and communication breakdowns are recurring concerns in the lower-rated feedback.
Recent client quotes
Jacob started my case with saving me with appeals and covered everything from Hague convention all the way to criminal. From local courts all the way to federal court... fights as if it was his fight, but even will guide you the best plan of action and strategically plan out your case with you.
Many lawyers didn't take my case as seriously as they should have initially. Jacob moved quickly and competently and did a wonderful job of cleaning up my very messy case.
Service was slow. Communication was cryptic when client begged for an update. Notice was not served on the defendant after weeks, even when physical whereabouts was provided.
Similar Attorneys
Law Offices of Brian D. Sloan
The Law Offices of Brian D. Sloan is a Phoenix-based practice that handles one thing: DUI defense across Arizona. Since…
View profile
Donaldson Law, LLC
Denver Personal Injury Attorneys - The Donaldson Law, LLC located in Denver, CO. At our law firm our personal injury…
View profile
Reitan Law Office
Reitan Law Office, PLLC is a Minnesota law firm with over 35 years of experience representing injured and disabled workers…
View profile