70 Niagara Street, Third Floor, Buffalo, New York 14202, United States

Harrington & Mahoney is a criminal defense firm based at 70 Niagara Street in downtown Buffalo, New York. The partnership was formed in 1995 when James P. Harrington and Mark J. Mahoney joined forces, building a practice focused on serious...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Harrington & Mahoney's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Harrington & Mahoney

Harrington & Mahoney is a criminal defense firm based at 70 Niagara Street in downtown Buffalo, New York. The partnership was formed in 1995 when James P. Harrington and Mark J. Mahoney joined forces, building a practice focused on serious state and federal matters across Western New York. The firm handles criminal defense, appeals and post-conviction relief, white-collar defense, and capital cases.

One feature sets the firm apart: it maintains what it describes as the only team of attorneys in North America devoted exclusively to defending autistic individuals charged with crimes, an "Autism Criminal Justice" practice that draws clients from well beyond the Buffalo area. The office is staffed by five attorneys, including partners Harrington and Mahoney alongside Catherine Armitage Berchou, Winter E. Eaton, and Zachary E. Buncy.

Lead attorney James P. Harrington has practiced law since 1969 and is a Past President of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. He was among the first attorneys certified for capital defense in New York after the state reinstated the death penalty in 1995 and has lectured on the subject at SUNY Buffalo Law School. His courtroom record includes securing bail for a defendant in the nationally covered "Lackawanna Six" terrorism case and prevailing in a Trading With the Enemy Act prosecution.

Independent analysis · Public records

Harrington & Mahoney: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
74 / 100
Strong

What is the reputation and track record of Harrington & Mahoney?

Harrington & Mahoney earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 74/100 (Strong), based on public records and client feedback, with a 3.8-star client rating. The Buffalo criminal-defense firm is led by James P. Harrington, a past president of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers practicing since 1969. Its distinctive niche defending autistic clients draws recognition from families statewide, though a few reviewers cite communication concerns.

Harrington & Mahoney — LawyerUp.Network Score 74/100

Reputation & results

69 / 100
  • 3.8★ · 14 reviews Client rating
  • Secured bail for a Lackawanna Six defendant in a national terrorism case High-profile federal defense Also prevailed in a Trading With the Enemy Act matter.

Experience

82 / 100
  • ~57 years (since 1969) Years practicing law Entered private criminal practice in 1974 after starting in 1969.

Recognition

78 / 100
  • Statewide criminal-defense bar leadership Past President, NY State Assoc. of Criminal Defense Lawyers Listed as a past leader in NYSACDL records.
  • Peer-reviewed selection for criminal defense (2007) Peer recognition Per firm bio.
  • Among the first NY attorneys certified for capital cases after 1995 NY capital-defense certification Also lectured on death-penalty defense at SUNY Buffalo Law.

Credentials

Education

JD, State University of New York at Buffalo School of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in NY

Professional Associations

New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (Past President)
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Harrington & Mahoney

Last update: July 29, 2026

3.8
Based on 14 reviews (via Google)

Harrington & Mahoney earns particular recognition for a niche few firms occupy: criminal defense for autistic clients, where partner Mark Mahoney is repeatedly singled out by families for post-conviction and trial work. Reviewers describe him as knowledgeable and straightforward, supported by office staff they found helpful and responsive.

Feedback is largely positive but not uniform. Multiple clients highlight strong courtroom knowledge and better-than-expected results, while one reviewer reported difficulty reaching the firm over billing after an initial payment. Prospective clients may find it useful to clarify communication and fee expectations up front.

Responsiveness 3.6/5
Expertise 4.2/5
Transparency on fees 3.8/5
Case outcomes 4.0/5

Recent client quotes

Mark Mahoney is a wonderful autism defense attorney. He did a post conviction petition for my autistic son. All of the staff in his office are just wonderful and very helpful.
Carol I. via Google
He explained the process with depth and understanding of circumstances. Results were more desirable than expected given the situation.
D G. via Google