2470 Walden Ave, Buffalo, NY 14225, United States
Brown Chiari is a plaintiff-side personal injury and medical malpractice firm serving Western New York from offices on Walden Avenue in Buffalo and in the Rochester area. Roughly fifteen attorneys handle medical negligence, nursing home neglect, motor vehicle and truck...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout Brown Chiari
Brown Chiari is a plaintiff-side Personal Injury and Medical Malpractice firm serving Western New York from offices on Walden Avenue in Buffalo and in the Rochester area. Roughly fifteen attorneys handle medical negligence, nursing home neglect, motor vehicle and truck collisions, construction and Labor Law injuries, and defective product claims.
Name partners James E. Brown and Donald P. Chiari built the practice around courtroom work rather than volume settlement. Chiari earned his J.D. cum laude from the State University of New York at Buffalo Law School and has more than 35 years in practice. He was inducted in 2019 as a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers, an invitation-only body capped at one percent of the lawyers in any state, and holds the Advocate rank in the American Board of Trial Advocates. Brown has served as a National Board Representative for that same organization.
The firm's published results include a $20 million wrongful death verdict in a motor vehicle case, the largest in Niagara County history, and an $8.9 million auto verdict recorded as the county's second largest. Its medical and catastrophic injury work has produced a $28.5 million settlement for a child who lost a limb, a $9.6 million recovery for a brain-damaged infant, and a $1.5 million bedsore verdict that ranks among the highest returned against a New York nursing home. Product Liability verdicts of $5.45 million and $3.8 million both involved failures in exercise equipment.
Intake for both offices runs through the Buffalo number, (716) 681-7190.
Brown Chiari: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of Brown Chiari?
Brown Chiari holds a LawyerUp.Network Score of 83/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.4-star client rating. A $20 million wrongful death verdict stands as the highest in Niagara County history, and an $8.9 million auto verdict as the second highest. Name partner Donald P. Chiari has been a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers since 2019, an invitation-only body capped at one percent of any state's lawyers.
Reputation & results
- 4.4★ · 154 reviews Client rating
- $20M wrongful death verdict — the highest in Niagara County history; $8.9M auto verdict, the county's second highest Track record Other published results include a $28.5M settlement for a child who lost a limb, a $9.6M recovery for a brain-damaged infant, and a $1.5M bedsore verdict among the highest returned against a New York nursing home.
Experience
- 35+ years in practice Years licensed Name partner Donald P. Chiari; co-founder James E. Brown reports a comparable multi-decade trial career in Western New York.
- Active, good standing — no public discipline found Bar standing No disciplinary orders located for either name partner.
Recognition
- Fellow, American College of Trial Lawyers — invitation only, capped at 1% of a state's lawyers Selective fellowship Donald P. Chiari, Fellow since 2019. He also holds the Advocate rank in the American Board of Trial Advocates.
- Former National Board Representative, American Board of Trial Advocates; National Advisory Board, University at Buffalo Law Advocacy Institute Academy and academic leadership ABOTA board role held by James E. Brown; the law-school advocacy board seat is held by Donald P. Chiari.
- Peer-recognized in personal injury and medical malpractice litigation Peer recognition Both name partners carry the top peer-review rating for legal ability and ethics.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about Brown Chiari
Last update: July 22, 2026
Brown Chiari carries a 4.4 rating across more than 150 reviews, a substantial sample for a Western New York plaintiff firm, and the feedback reads as a firm where individual attorneys build direct relationships with their clients rather than routing work through a case-management layer. David Olson draws the largest share of named praise, followed by Donald Chiari and Michael Scinta.
The accounts that carry the most detail involve long-running litigation. One reviewer describes a case that ran nearly seven years to a win, crediting steady communication throughout; another describes an insurer's delay tactics being cut short when emergency back surgery became necessary. Paralegal Nadine Reformat is named alongside her attorney in several reviews, which suggests clients experience the firm as a small team on each file.
Reviewers consistently mention being kept informed and having the procedural steps explained in terms they could follow, and several describe representation spanning multiple family members. The tone across the sample is confident about the firm's litigation depth in car accident, medical negligence and nursing home matters.
Recent client quotes
Don Chiari is incredibly knowledgeable and took the time to clearly explain every step of the process, making me feel confident and informed throughout.
My case went on for almost 7 years, and he never quit. We won. I was advised properly and professionally.
Every detail was handled with skill, compassion, and in a timely manner. David is thorough, honest, and showed genuine concern throughout the process.
Similar Attorneys
Marsh, Rickard & Bryan
Marsh, Rickard & Bryan is a Birmingham trial firm that represents seriously injured people and grieving families in personal injury,…
View profileKevin McManus Law
Kevin McManus Law is a Kansas City personal injury and disability practice led by founder and managing attorney Kevin J.…
View profile
Truck Crash Attorneys – Samer Habbas & Associates
Truck Crash Attorneys is the truck-accident practice of The Law Offices of Samer Habbas & Associates, PC, the Southern California…
View profile