Craig, Kelley & Faultless - Indianapolis

1 case waiting — claim now

5845 Lawton Loop E Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46216, United States

Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC is an Indiana personal injury firm founded in 1999 by David W. Craig, William J. Kelley II, and Scott A. Faultless. The practice concentrates heavily on truck and semi-truck collisions, car accidents, and wrongful death...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Craig, Kelley & Faultless - Indianapolis's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Craig, Kelley & Faultless - Indianapolis

Craig, Kelley & Faultless LLC is an Indiana Personal Injury firm founded in 1999 by David W. Craig, William J. Kelley II, and Scott A. Faultless. The practice concentrates heavily on truck and semi-truck collisions, car accidents, and Wrongful Death claims, and reports having recovered hundreds of millions of dollars in settlements and verdicts for injured clients across more than three decades of work.

Lead partner David W. Craig has been admitted to the Indiana bar since 1985 and sits on the board of the Academy of Truck Accident Attorneys, reflecting the firm's particular depth in catastrophic trucking cases. His honors include back-to-back Litigator Awards for Truck Accidents (2014 and 2015), a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating, and recognition in The Best Lawyers in America. The attorney roster also includes Alexander R. Craig, Christopher Barry, Samantha Stevens, and Whitney Coker.

The firm maintains a substantial Indiana footprint, with its headquarters at 5845 Lawton Loop E Dr in Indianapolis and additional offices on the city's south side and in Avon, Batesville, Richmond, and Evansville. It also serves Missouri clients through a St. Louis location at 5585 Pershing Avenue. A 24-hour toll-free line and a shared [email protected] inbox handle intake from injury victims throughout the region.

Independent analysis · Public records

Craig, Kelley & Faultless - Indianapolis: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
89 / 100
Excellent

What is the reputation and track record of Craig, Kelley & Faultless - Indianapolis?

Craig, Kelley & Faultless – Indianapolis earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 89/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.9-star client rating. Founded in 1999, the Indiana firm concentrates heavily on truck and semi-truck collisions. Managing partner David W. Craig, admitted in 1985, and partner Scott A. Faultless both hold Truck Accident Law board certification from the National Board of Trial Advocacy, and Craig sits on the Academy of Truck Accident Attorneys' Board of Regents.

Craig, Kelley & Faultless - Indianapolis — LawyerUp.Network Score 89/100

Reputation & results

88 / 100
  • 4.9★ · 645 reviews Client rating
  • Counsel of record in published Indiana Court of Appeals decision Appellate practice Firm attorneys have appeared before the Indiana Supreme Court, Indiana Court of Appeals, and U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit.

Experience

95 / 100
  • 41+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead/managing partner David W. Craig admitted in Indiana in 1985.
  • Active, good standing - no public discipline Bar standing

Recognition

87 / 100
  • Truck Accident Law - National Board of Trial Advocacy (ABA-accredited) Board-certified specialist Two firm partners (David W. Craig and Scott A. Faultless) hold this credential - among only ~4 such board-certified attorneys in Indiana.
  • Board of Regents, Academy of Truck Accident Attorneys National academy leadership Lead attorney serves on the governing Board of Regents of a selective national truck-litigation academy.
  • Peer-recognized; named among top trial lawyers in Indiana Peer & industry recognition

Credentials

Education

JD, Indiana University Robert H. McKinney School of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in IN

Professional Associations

Academy of Truck Accident Attorneys (Board of Regents) Trial Lawyers Board of Regents
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Craig, Kelley & Faultless – Indianapolis

Last update: June 4, 2026

4.9
Based on 645 reviews (via Google)

Craig, Kelley & Faultless holds a 4.9-star aggregate across more than 640 reviews, one of the deepest review records among Indiana injury firms. Clients consistently praise attorney Krysten LeFavour and a named support team — including Jade Belstra, Jenna, and Gena — for steady communication and compassion after serious crashes.

Reviewers describe attorneys who take over the stress of insurance negotiations, provide realistic timelines, and stay in regular contact through long recoveries. Many emphasize feeling heard and supported rather than treated as a case number.

The firm's particular depth in trucking and auto collision cases comes through in repeated mentions of favorable outcomes and confident handling of complex claims.

Responsiveness 4.9/5
Expertise 4.8/5
Transparency on fees 4.7/5
Case outcomes 4.8/5

Recent client quotes

Krysten LeFavour has done a phenomenal job. My case wasn't an easy one but she stuck through it and had her team going the extra mile.
Tom W. via Google
They handled everything and I didn't have to stress about any of it. Their paralegal Jenna kept me updated every step of the way.
Yesac S. via Google
I felt heard, cared for, and understood this entire process. They gave me realistic timeframes and always had my best interest at heart.
Amber B. via Google