7000 W. North Avenue, Wauwatosa, WI 53213, United States
Kuchler & Cotton, S.C. is a Wauwatosa-based criminal defense firm serving clients throughout the Milwaukee area and Eastern Wisconsin, with a secondary appointments-only office in Waukesha. Founding partners Donna Kuchler (admitted 1996) and Anthony Cotton (admitted 2005) lead a five-attorney...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout Kuchler & Cotton
Kuchler & Cotton, S.C. is a Wauwatosa-based criminal defense firm serving clients throughout the Milwaukee area and Eastern Wisconsin, with a secondary appointments-only office in Waukesha. Founding partners Donna Kuchler (admitted 1996) and Anthony Cotton (admitted 2005) lead a five-attorney team handling state and federal matters across Waukesha, Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Walworth, Jefferson, Washington, Dane, Brown, and Outagamie counties.
The firm's white-collar practice covers fraud, theft, internet crimes, and complex financial cases, with both partners admitted to the U.S. District Courts for the Eastern and Western Districts of Wisconsin and the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. Donna Kuchler has won the Martin Hanson Award twice (2005, 2014) for prevailing at criminal homicide trials and received the William Coffey Memorial Award for contributions to criminal justice professionalism.
Anthony Cotton served as President of the Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers from 2015 to 2017 and sits on the Board of Directors of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, where he was elected at age 28. Both partners have earned Super Lawyers recognition annually for over a decade, and the WACDL named an award after Donna Kuchler in recognition of her contributions to the defense bar.
Kuchler & Cotton: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of Kuchler & Cotton?
Kuchler & Cotton earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 87/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 4.8-star client rating. The Wauwatosa criminal defense firm is anchored by founder Donna Kuchler, admitted in Wisconsin in 1996, and partner Anthony Cotton, past President of the Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. The firm's appellate work includes a Fourth Amendment suppression win at the U.S. Seventh Circuit.
Reputation & results
- 4.8★ · 82 reviews Client rating
- Won Fourth Amendment suppression at the Seventh Circuit Published appellate result United States v. Robeles-Ortega, 348 F.3d 679 (7th Cir. 2003) - federal appeal in which the defense prevailed on a motion to suppress evidence.
Experience
- 30+ yrs licensed Years licensed Founding attorney Donna Kuchler admitted to the Wisconsin Bar in 1996.
- Active, good standing - no public discipline Bar standing
Recognition
- State criminal-defense bar President; national board director Bar leadership Partner Anthony Cotton served as President of the Wisconsin Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (2015-2017) and was elected to the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers Board of Directors.
- Peer-recognized criminal defense attorneys Peer recognition Founder also received WACDL's Martin Hanson Award (for winning a criminal homicide trial), with a WACDL award later named in her honor.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about Kuchler & Cotton
Last update: May 25, 2026
Kuchler & Cotton carries a 4.8-star aggregate across 82 Google reviews, and the recent commentary describes an active criminal defense practice where founding partners Donna Kuchler and Anthony 'Tony' Cotton, along with attorney Jason Findling, are repeatedly named for direct involvement in client cases. Reviewers describe serious felony matters — including charges the clients say they did not commit — being dismantled methodically through careful evidence review and strategic courtroom work.
Recurring themes center on responsiveness, deep Wisconsin law knowledge, and a willingness to take cases to trial. Anthony Cotton draws repeat-client praise for representing one family across three separate cases in three different counties, and reviewers consistently describe him as well-versed in Wisconsin law, respected in the court system, and accessible whenever clients reach out. Donna Kuchler is described as treating clients like family, with meticulous attention to detail and tireless work on serious matters that reviewers credit with life-changing outcomes.
Reviewers emphasize that the attorneys deliver real, favorable results — successful innocence-establishing defense work, favorable resolutions in negotiation, and trial readiness when needed. The firm's white-collar focus is reflected in the methodical, evidence-driven approach reviewers describe, and clients across multiple matter types and Wisconsin counties praise the consistent professionalism and case outcomes from both partners and the broader team.
Recent client quotes
Anthony truly took the time to understand my case and fought hard for the best possible outcome. He was always there when I needed him—whether it was answering questions, calming my worries, or just being incredibly responsive.
Donna and Jason took the time to pick apart all of the information presented to them and truly decipher how to prove innocence. Not only were they thorough, but they were thoughtful, intelligent, diligent, and ultimately successful.
He represented my son in three different cases in three different counties in the state. He is very well versed in Wisconsin Law and greatly respected in the court system.
Similar Attorneys
JPLaw
JPLaw is the Kansas City practice of trial attorney John Anthony Picerno, who has handled criminal-defense and civil-rights matters from…
View profile
Brown Paindiris & Scott
Brown Paindiris & Scott, LLP is a full-service Connecticut law firm whose lawyers handle personal injury claims, criminal defense, divorce…
View profile
Dunlap Fiore
Dunlap Fiore is a Baton Rouge law firm founded by named partners John B. Dunlap III and Jennifer A. Fiore,…
View profile