Benckendorf & Benckendorf

Is this your firm? Claim it for free

101 NE Randolph Ave, Peoria, IL 61606, United States

Benckendorf & Benckendorf, P.C. has served central Illinois since its founding in 1981 by brothers Glenn E. Benckendorf and David A. Benckendorf. The firm operates from two offices, in Peoria and Morton, providing a broad range of civil legal services...

Read full profile

LawyerUp AI Assistant

Online · Your legal matchmaker
Hey! You're checking out Benckendorf & Benckendorf's profile. I can tell you about their experience, what they're great at, and whether they're the right fit. If they are, I'll help you submit your case in seconds — completely free. What's your situation? Lawyer up!
Not legal advice. For informational purposes only.
Prefer to browse our directory yourself?

About Benckendorf & Benckendorf

Benckendorf & Benckendorf, P.C. has served central Illinois since its founding in 1981 by brothers Glenn E. Benckendorf and David A. Benckendorf. The firm operates from two offices, in Peoria and Morton, providing a broad range of civil legal services in a small-firm setting without the bureaucracy of larger practices.

The firm's Business Law practice covers business organizations, formation, contracts, and related counsel for central Illinois companies. Alongside business matters, Benckendorf & Benckendorf handles Estate Planning, probate, and real estate work, with the Morton office serving as the firm's center for real estate transactions.

Partner James W. Benckendorf joined his father and brother in the practice in 1988 and brings roughly 38 years of experience, holding a Leading Lawyer designation from Law Bulletin Media. The firm's attorneys also include partner Lynne M. Binkele and associates Emily D. Crutchfield, Noah Benckendorf, and Noah Dwyer. Several attorneys are active in community organizations across the Peoria and Morton areas, and the firm has long offered seminars on wills, estate planning, residential real estate, and Elder Law.

Independent analysis · Public records

Benckendorf & Benckendorf: reputation & track record

LawyerUp.Network Score
78 / 100
Strong

What is the reputation and track record of Benckendorf & Benckendorf?

Benckendorf & Benckendorf earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 78/100 (Strong), based on public records and client feedback, with a 3.85-star client rating. Brothers Glenn and David Benckendorf founded the central Illinois practice in 1981, and it now runs from offices in Peoria and Morton. Lead attorney James W. Benckendorf, admitted in 1988 with a clean ARDC record, has been named a Leading Lawyer through peer nomination.

Benckendorf & Benckendorf — LawyerUp.Network Score 78/100

Reputation & results

70 / 100
  • 3.85★ · 33 reviews Client rating

Experience

95 / 100
  • 38+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead attorney James W. Benckendorf admitted to the Illinois bar in 1988.
  • Active, good standing - no public discipline Bar standing Illinois ARDC registration record shows active status with no public disciplinary record found.

Recognition

70 / 100
  • Peer-recognized attorney (Leading Lawyer) Peer-recognized James W. Benckendorf named a Leading Lawyer by Law Bulletin Media, a peer-nominated distinction.

Credentials

Education

JD, Northern Illinois University College of Law

Bar Admissions

Admitted in IL

Professional Associations

Peoria County Bar Association
Client insights

What Clients Say

What clients say about Benckendorf & Benckendorf

Last update: July 22, 2026

3.9
Based on 33 reviews (via Google)

Benckendorf & Benckendorf draws consistently positive feedback for its estate planning and business law services, with several clients praising attorney responsiveness, legal depth, and professionalism. Long-term clients note the team's quick follow-up and collaborative approach when managing ongoing business needs. Estate planning clients specifically commend speed of execution, clear cost disclosure upfront, and accommodating handling of revisions. A real estate client found the firm direct and efficient, completing deed transfers without unnecessary delays or rework.

Client experience is uneven, however, particularly around office administration and communication protocols. Multiple reviewers report friction with administrative staff — including allegations that a receptionist was dismissive, an office manager was inflexible about insurance coverage and service scope, and unhelpful communication during prolonged matters. Two divorces and one real estate matter received criticism for billing practices: a divorce case saw bills roughly double the initial estimate, another dragged two years with substantial monthly charges including per-contact fees, and a third client reported the attorney misstated communications with opposing counsel. One real estate case ended in victory but drew complaints that opposing counsel at another firm (Casey Kepple) provided superior ethical representation.

Trait performance splits by service area: the firm appears strongest in structured estate and business matters handled with defined scope, where clients report clarity and professionalism. Litigation and high-touch advisory work shows more variability, with communication breakdowns and billing concerns surfacing when cases extend or require frequent client contact.

Responsiveness 3.5/5
Expertise 4.0/5
Transparency on fees 3.2/5
Case outcomes 4.0/5

Recent client quotes

Jim Benckendorf in 2020 about starting an LLC and he was patient, knowledgeable, and generally helpful during our process to start a business...the responsiveness of the legal team...quick follow up to questions.
Stevy Barrett via Google
Lynne Binkele to handle my will, trust, and related documents. Lynne (and the whole firm) is very professional and caring...completed the work very quickly and accurately...extremely understanding about making changes...up front about the costs.
Johanna Christiansen via Google
My final bill from this attorney was at least twice what he originally estimated. He didn't honor my requests for how he shared documents with me. The costs kept creeping up...
Verified client via Google