401 W A St, Suite 2200, San Diego, CA 92101, United States
Shustak Reynolds & Partners is a nationally recognized securities and business law firm headquartered in downtown San Diego. For over 40 years, the firm has represented broker-dealers, investment advisers, hedge funds, financial institutions, and registered persons in complex securities litigation...
Read full profileLawyerUp AI Assistant
Online · Your legal matchmakerAbout Shustak Reynolds - San Diego
Shustak Reynolds & Partners is a nationally recognized securities and Business Law firm headquartered in downtown San Diego. For over 40 years, the firm has represented broker-dealers, investment advisers, hedge funds, financial institutions, and registered persons in complex securities litigation and arbitration.
The practice covers SEC and FINRA investigations, enforcement actions, regulatory compliance, and corporate transactions. With offices across the country, the San Diego office on West A Street serves as the firm home base for its experienced securities attorneys. The firm deep expertise in financial services law makes it a trusted resource for professionals navigating the heavily regulated securities industry.
Shustak Reynolds - San Diego: reputation & track record
What is the reputation and track record of Shustak Reynolds - San Diego?
Shustak Reynolds – San Diego earns a LawyerUp.Network Score of 84/100 (Excellent), based on public records and client feedback, with a 5-star client rating. Lead attorney Erwin J. Shustak, admitted in 1976 and a New York University School of Law graduate, has held the highest AV peer rating since 1985 and served as a FINRA arbitrator for over 30 years. The securities firm documents a $622,000 FINRA arbitration award recovered for an 86-year-old investor.
Reputation & results
- 5★ · 5 reviews Client rating
- $622,000 FINRA arbitration award vs. Fidelity for an elderly investor Documented result $350,000 compensatory damages plus $272,000 in legal fees and costs, recovered for an 86-year-old investor.
- National securities, FINRA arbitration & financial-services litigation Practice focus Specialty firm; lead attorney has served as a FINRA arbitrator/panel chair for 30+ years.
Experience
- 50+ yrs licensed Years licensed Lead attorney Erwin J. Shustak admitted to the bar in 1976 (practicing since 1976).
- Active, good standing - no public discipline found Bar standing California State Bar #119152, also admitted in New York and New Jersey.
- New York University School of Law (JD, cum laude) Lead attorney law school NYU Law is a U.S. News Top-14 law school; Shustak served on the NYU Law Review.
Recognition
- Peer-rated AV (highest tier) since 1985; Top 100 litigation honors Peer-recognized standing Highest peer rating for professional excellence and ethics, held continuously for ~45 years.
Credentials
Education
Bar Admissions
Professional Associations
What Clients Say
What clients say about Shustak Reynolds – San Diego
Last update: May 20, 2026
Clients of Shustak Reynolds describe a firm that handles business and securities matters with composure and depth. Reviewers point to clear upfront explanations of process, prompt follow-through during the engagement, and an evident command of complex case work — including one client who turned to the firm after a significant business dispute and credits the attorney with walking them through each step methodically.
Paul Reynolds is singled out by name as a standout attorney, and the broader team draws repeat praise for attention to detail and integrity. Fees come up more than once and the framing is consistent: reasonable for the caliber of work, and aligned with what clients expected going in rather than a surprise on the back end.
The recurring picture is a firm that takes complicated business problems seriously, communicates without making clients chase updates, and prices the work in line with the depth of representation provided.
Recent client quotes
The attorney I worked with explained the process with me upfront and communicated with me promptly at every step along the way. The fee structure was as expected for this level of service and the attention to detail was impressive.
We had a complex case & they addressed everything top notch with reasonable fees. From beginning to end, they upheld integrity and excellence and placed our best interest at the core of their practices.
Paul Reynolds is the best Attorney I have ever worked with!! I would recommend anyone looking for an attorney to represent them to hire Paul.
Similar Attorneys
Mette, Evans & Woodside
Mette, Evans & Woodside is a Central Pennsylvania law firm practicing from its longtime headquarters at 3401 North Front Street…
View profile
Resolvere Law
Resolvere Law is a Phoenix litigation practice handling real estate, construction, and business disputes for clients across Arizona, including nearby…
View profile
Schnitzer Johnson & Watson
Schnitzer Johnson & Watson, CHTD. is a Las Vegas civil litigation firm whose core work is insurance defense, professional liability…
View profile